Introduction:

When it comes to managing your hair throughout the day, whether you’re in a HIIT class or sitting in a board meeting, it’s all about finding the right tools that work for you. Hair ties often struggle with breaking at the most inconvenient times, making you constantly need to readjust your hair. For ambitious women who juggle a busy life, this can be frustrating. That’s where the choice between a scrunchie and a pro hair tie comes into play.

With superior durability and agility, a well-designed hair tie is built to handle constant use without compromising on hair care. Some companies, especially a good hair tie company, understand that your time is valuable, and they craft products accordingly to suit your hair type and lifestyle. Whether you’re working out or at a meeting, making the switch to a more reliable option is key to keeping your hair in place, stylish, and well-managed.
Finding the right hair tie for thick hair can often feel like a struggle due to the constant evolution of hair accessory trends. With an endless array of options, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed when searching for the perfect one. Scrunchies and elastic hair ties have become the clear favorites among hair tie enthusiasts, but each comes with its own set of pros and cons. Making an informed decision about which is the best option for your hair type can save you time and hassle in the long run, ensuring your hair stays stylish and secure all day.

What Are Hair Ties?

The history of hair ties stretches back centuries to ancient civilizations like Egypt, Greece, and Rome, where people used ribbons, cords, and leather strips to secure their hair. These early hair ties served both functional and ornamental purposes, reflecting personal style, social status, and cultural identity. Over time, hair ties evolved with fashion and societal trends.

In the Renaissance and Baroque periods, hair accessories became more elaborate, featuring ribbons, bows, and ornaments. By the 18th and 19th centuries, maintaining a well-groomed appearance was key, with women using silk cords and men using ribbons to secure their hair.

The 20th century brought the invention of elastic, revolutionizing hair ties, and the scrunchie in the 1960s became a stylish, gentle option, gaining massive popularity in the ’80s and ’90s. Today, modern hair ties like scrunchies and spiral hair ties offer diverse options for all hair types, combining functionality with fashion. The core purpose of hair ties remains: to help people manage and express themselves through their hair.

What Are Scrunchies?

Scrunchies, also known as fabric hair ties, were invented in the 1960s and became a huge trend in the ’80s and ’90s. These beloved hair accessories have seen a major resurgence recently, being popular across all age groups. Made by sewing a soft, stretchy fabric around an elastic band, scrunchies are known for their fluffy, gathered, and voluminous look. They’re not just functional but also add a stylish flair to any hairdo.

Available in a variety of sizes, materials, colors, and patterns, scrunchies are incredibly versatile and fashionable, making them a great choice for all hair types and personal styles. Whether you want something small and discreet or an oversized, statement-making piece, there’s a scrunchie for every occasion. Crafted from materials like cotton, polyester, satin, velvet, or silk, each scrunchie offers unique benefits and an added layer of aesthetic appeal.

Benefits of Using Scrunchies for Hair:

Gentle on hair: Scrunchies, or fabric hair ties, are an excellent choice for anyone looking to be gentle on their hair. Made from soft and smooth materials, scrunchies offer a gentle grip on thick hair, unlike elastic hair ties which create friction and tension. This can help minimize damage to your hair over time, making them perfect for daily use without causing unnecessary strain.

Comfortable to wear: One of the biggest advantages of scrunchies is that they are incredibly comfortable to wear. Unlike tight elastics, scrunchies don’t cause headaches or scalp discomfort. They can even be worn while sleeping to prevent hair breakage.

Range of style: With their range of styles, from classic velvet to fun prints and patterns, you can easily find a scrunchie that suits your personal style. Some even feature embellishments like beads, sequins, or bows, adding an extra touch of flair to your hairstyle.

No Creases: Another great benefit is that scrunchies leave no creases in the hair, unlike traditional hair ties that can leave an unsightly dent. This makes scrunchies ideal for people who frequently change hairstyles or want to let their hair down after a long day.

Reduces Hair Tangling: Additionally, scrunchies are effective in reducing hair tangling, especially when made from silk or other smooth materials. The smooth texture helps minimize friction and prevent knots, which is especially helpful for those with long hair or curly hair, both of which are more prone to tangling.

Drawbacks of Using Scrunchies for Hair:

While scrunchies are known for being gentle and comfortable, they often have a limited hold, especially when compared to elastic hair ties. For people with thick or heavy hair, this can be a challenge. Scrunchies may not offer the stronghold needed to keep your hair in place during vigorous activities, which can cause the hair to come loose or look messy.

Another downside is the price. Scrunchies, particularly those made with high-quality materials, can be more expensive than regular elastic hair ties. This higher price point can make scrunchies less accessible for some people who are looking for a more affordable option.

Lastly, scrunchies tend to be bulky due to their larger size and the fabric used in their design. This makes them bulkier and takes up more space compared to elastic hair ties. They can be less convenient to carry in a purse, bag, or pocket, which might not be ideal for those who need a compact, easily portable hair accessory.

What Are Elastic Hair Ties?

Elastic hair ties, also known as hair elastics, elastic ties, ponytail holders, or elastic bands, are simple loops made from elastic material designed to hold hair securely. These hair ties are a classic, tried-and-true accessory that has been a staple in many people’s hair care arsenal for decades. They come in various sizes, colors, and materials to fit different hair types, thicknesses, and personal preferences.

Some elastic hair ties are made from basic rubber or synthetic materials, while others are covered with fabric or woven materials for extra comfort and style. They can be thin and discreet or thicker and more robust, depending on the level of hold needed for a specific hairstyle. Whether you need a light grip or a stronger hold, these hair ties offer flexibility to suit your needs.

Benefits of Using Elastic Hair Ties for Thick Hair:

Strong hold: One of the biggest advantages of elastic hair ties for thick hair is their strong hold. These ties are designed to keep hair in place during intense activities like a workout or any physical activity. Whether you’re wearing a sleek ponytail or a bun, your hairstyle stays intact and secure, ensuring you can go through your day without worrying about your hair coming loose.

Less Bulk: Another great benefit of elastic hair ties is that they come with less bulk compared to scrunchies. They are smaller and less noticeable, making them a great choice for those who prefer a minimalist and discreet look. Their low-profile design allows them to blend seamlessly with your thicker hair type, creating a sleek and polished look that’s perfect for any occasion.

Used for Multiple Hairstyles: Elastic hair ties are also highly versatile and can be used for multiple hairstyles such as ponytails, braids, buns, and twists. Their versatility makes them ideal for casual, everyday looks as well as more intricate and formal styles. Whether you’re heading to the gym or dressing up for an event, elastic ties can handle it all.

Durable: Durability is another important feature of these hair ties. Made from stretchy materials like rubber or silicone, they can withstand repeated use and exposure to water and sweat without stretching out or losing grip. This makes them a long-lasting investment for those with thick hair.

Affordable: Additionally, elastic hair ties are more affordable, with a lower price point than scrunchies, allowing you to experiment with different colors, styles, and sizes without breaking the bank.

Drawbacks of Using Elastic Hair Ties: Can Cause Damage: While elastic hair ties are popular for keeping hair in place, they can sometimes cause damage. The tight grip needed to secure thick hair often leads to breakage, split ends, and overall hair weakening, especially if you frequently wear your hair up. Over time, this tension on your hair can result in significant harm, making it less healthy.

Uncomfortable to Wear: Another common issue with elastic ties is that they can be uncomfortable for people with a sensitive scalp. The tightness can create pain, discomfort, and even headaches if worn for long periods.
May Create a “Ponytail Bump”: Additionally, elastic ties may leave a ponytail bump, a visible bump or dent in the hair caused by the tie compressing the strands. This indentation can be frustrating for those looking for a smooth, bump-free hairstyle after letting their hair down.

May Not Be Suitable for All Hair Textures: Elastic ties are not always suitable for all hair textures. For instance, those with coils or curly hair might experience breakage due to the tension these ties create.

Tangling: They can also lead to tangling, particularly with rubber or thinner materials, which can become entangled in thick or curly hair. This is especially true for individuals with coarse thick hair, as their texture is more prone to tangling.

So, Which is Better for Thick Hair?

Choosing between scrunchies and elastic hair ties depends on your personal preferences and the specific needs of your thick hair. If you want something gentle and comfortable, scrunchies may be the better option. Their soft fabric is gentle on the scalp and they are less likely to cause damage to your hair. Plus, scrunchies can add a fun accessory to your outfit, making them a stylish choice.

On the other hand, if you need a stronghold to hold thick strands in place during physical activity like workouts or sports, then elastic hair ties might be more suitable. These ties are designed to keep hair secure and offer a sleek appearance that can give your hairstyle a more polished look.

Tips for Choosing the Right Hair Tie:

When choosing a hair tie for thick hair, it’s important to consider various factors that match your unique hair needs. For example, you may need a tie that is strong, long-lasting, and has a larger diameter to handle the volume and density of your hair. A hair tie that securely holds strands in place without causing damage is crucial, so trying different sizes and strengths can help you find the perfect fit.

It’s also important to find a hair tie that is gentle on your hair. Opt for ties made from soft, gentle materials that can minimize hair stress. Look for features like seamless designs, fabric coatings, and wide bands that distribute pressure evenly to prevent breakage. Whether you’re wearing a ponytail, bun, or braid, switching up your hair tie placement can help reduce repetitive stress on one spot, preventing thinning and split ends.

When considering different materials, think about what works best for your hair type. Cotton, velvet, satin, and rubber all offer unique benefits and drawbacks. For instance, satin and silk scrunchies are gentler on hair and help retain moisture, while silicone ties provide a secure grip for more active lifestyles.

Lastly, your hair texture plays a big role in choosing the right tie. If you have wavy, textured, or curly hair, selecting ties that minimize frizz and reduce tangling is key. Satin scrunchies are particularly helpful for maintaining your natural texture, reducing friction, and providing a secure yet comfortable hold.

Conclusion:

In conclusion, choosing the right hair tie for your thick hair comes down to understanding your unique hair needs and finding a balance between strength and gentleness. Whether you opt for scrunchies for their soft, gentle materials or elastic hair ties for their secure hold during active lifestyles, it’s essential to consider factors like hair type, thickness, and how to minimize damage. By experimenting with different sizes, materials, and placement, you can find the perfect hair tie that not only complements your style but also keeps your hair healthy and secure.